When assessing the inventiveness of patent applications, IPO and courts often encounter statements in the prior art that discourage or suggest certain approaches are ineffective. These statements, often referred to as ‘teaching away,’ are understood to guide a person skilled in the art away from specific combinations or solutions. A recent example is 113-Year Xing Zhuan Su Zi №31 Judgment (2025) by the IP Court, concerning a patent invalidation case involving a soft candy invention. The core issue in that case was whether combining Evidence 1 and Evidence 2 would render the claimed invention obvious.

Based on the court’s analysis, the IPO initially concluded that the patent possessed inventiveness. It appears that the IPO placed significant weight on a potential “teach away” present in Evidence 2. Evidence 2 allegedly stated that if the gelatin content was less than 2% by weight, the desired “sticky and chewy texture” could not be sustained. Given that the patent in question included a gelatin content range of “0.2 weight% or more and less than 2 weight%”, the IPO seemingly reasoned that this teach away would deter a person skilled in the art from combining Evidence 1 (which also disclosed a gelatin content within the claimed range) with Evidence 2.
However, the IP Court overturned the IPO’s decision, finding the patent claims to lack inventiveness based on the combination of prior art. The court adopted a more in-depth and contextual approach to evaluating the alleged “teach away”.
The court emphasized several key points in its reasoning:
- Shared Technical Field and Problem: Both Evidence 1 and Evidence 2 belonged to the technical field of soft candies and aimed to improve their texture, particularly elasticity.
- Common Functionality: Both prior art documents disclosed using aeration (introducing gas bubbles) to reduce the specific gravity of the candy. Evidence 1 described stirring the candy ingredients to incorporate air, implicitly lowering the specific gravity, while Evidence 2 explicitly described using a foaming machine to control the specific gravity within a range of 0.6 to 1.1.
- Context-Specific Nature of the “Teach Away”: The court highlighted that the “teach away” in Evidence 2 regarding low gelatin content was specifically linked to achieving a “sticky and chewy texture”. This differed from the objectives of the claimed invention, which aimed for a “lighter and richer texture, and a firm chewiness” .
- Independent Control of Specific Gravity: The court noted that Evidence 2 clearly stated that the specific gravity was primarily adjusted through the amount of foaming (aeration) and was not dependent on the gelatin content. Therefore, a skilled person seeking to achieve a lighter texture (as in the claimed invention) would not necessarily be dissuaded by the “teach away” concerning gelatin when considering the specific gravity ranges disclosed in Evidence 2.
- Motivation to Combine Despite the “Teach Away”: Given the shared technical field, similar goals in improving texture through aeration, and the independent nature of specific gravity control, the court concluded that a person skilled in the art would have been motivated to combine the teachings of Evidence 1 and Evidence 2, particularly applying the specific gravity range disclosed in Evidence 2 to the soft candy described in Evidence 1 to achieve a lighter texture.
The court explicitly stated that a “teach away” does not automatically negate the possibility of combining prior art. Instead, a thorough examination of the reasons behind the “teach away” and its relevance to the objectives and effects of the claimed invention is necessary. In this case, the “teach away” in Evidence 2 was deemed irrelevant to the goal of achieving a lighter texture through specific gravity control.
Reference:
113-Year Xing Zhuan Su Zi №31 Ju113-Year Xing Zhuan Su Zi №31 Judgment (2025)dgment (2025)