Patent Licensing as Proof of Inventiveness? Taiwan’s Top Court Explains

Image from the original Medium article.
Image from the original Medium article.

The Taiwan Supreme Administrative Court’s Tai Shang Tzu №459 (2024) judgment, concerning a patent invalidation case, provides significant insights into how patent licensing can be considered as a supplementary factor in assessing the inventive step of a patent. This judgment, which overturned and remanded the Intellectual Property and Commercial Court’s (IP Court) decision, specifically addresses the weight that should be given to patent licensing agreements, particularly those involving competitors, when evaluating whether an invention is non-obvious to a person skilled in the art.

The Court emphasized that when an applicant presents supplementary evidence arguing for the patent’s inventiveness based on factors such as commercial success, which can be evidenced by patent licensing to competitors, such evidence should be duly considered. The court reasoned that competitors are the most likely entities to engage in research and development based on existing prior art. Therefore, if a significant number of competitors have entered into licensing agreements and are paying royalties for the patent, this could suggest that the patent possesses advantages over the prior art and thus exhibits inventive step.

However, the court also highlighted that the mere existence of licensing agreements is not conclusive proof of inventiveness. To properly assess the probative value of such agreements, several factors must be examined:

*Whether the licensee actively and willingly sought the license.

*Whether the license covers a single patent or multiple patents.

*The duration and scope of the license.

*The amount of royalties paid for the specific patent in question.

*The licensee’s motivation for obtaining the license.

*The licensee’s actual implementation of the patented technology.

The Supreme Administrative Court criticized the IP Court for dismissing the patent holder’s licensing evidence by stating that “signing a license is a commercial act, with many other considerations behind it”. The Court directly cited its previous Tai Shang Tzu №597 (2021) judgment and pointed out that the IP Court failed to adequately investigate the evidence presented by the patent holder regarding the licensing agreements, thereby violating the requirement in the Administrative Litigation Act that lower courts must base their judgments on the reasons for reversal provided by the Supreme Administrative Court.

The Court further noted the patent holder’s claim that major IC companies in Taiwan’s voice IC industry (with the exception of the opposing party) had sought licenses after carefully considering the patent’s content, and that the patented technology had been used in ICs exported in significant quantities. The court stated that, based on general logical reasoning and experience, this claim was not entirely unfounded and could influence the assessment of the patent’s inventiveness. The IP Court’s failure to thoroughly investigate these claims was deemed a violation of logical and empirical rules and a failure to investigate evidence ex officio.

In conclusion, the judgment clarifies that while patent licensing can be a relevant supplementary factor in evaluating inventiveness, particularly when licenses are granted to competitors, a comprehensive analysis of the circumstances surrounding these agreements is necessary. The court emphasized the need to examine the licensees’ motivations and the specific terms of the licenses to determine whether they genuinely indicate the inventiveness and technological contribution of the patented invention. This judgment underscores the importance of considering real-world commercial evidence alongside prior art and technical knowledge when assessing the inventive merit of a patent.

Reference: