Is AI Breaking the Balance of the Patent System?

The threshold for what constitutes an “Inventive Step” (or Non-obviousness) is facing unprecedented pressure from Artificial Intelligence.

🔹 Omniscience as the New Normal: The US is already moving toward viewing a PHOSITA as a person equipped with AI tools. Unlike humans, AI approaches “omniscience.” It knows too much.

🔹 The End of “Non-Analogous” Art: AI effortlessly connects dots across disparate fields. It retrieves and correlates prior art from everywhere, making almost everything “related art.”

🔹 Plummeting Experimentation Costs: With predictive models like AlphaFold, the cost of trial-and-error has collapsed. This dramatically raises the “reasonable expectation of success,” making breakthroughs look easier than they are.

The Dilemma: While AI supercharges R&D, it paradoxically raises the bar for patentability. If AI makes everything “obvious,” will any patent be granted?

If we raise the bar, the system might freeze. If we maintain current standards, we risk a flood of low-quality patents.

We are moving toward a future where PHOSITA isn’t just a human using AI, but AI itself — omniscient, objective, and adjustable. That is a wild concept to grasp.