【Patent ‘Common Sense’ is Key: Without Domain Knowledge, AI Only Generates Hallucinations】

Last week, the Patent Attorneys Association invited a CTO of an AI company to share how to “apply generative AI in the daily life of a patent attorney.”

The speaker was very well-known and had clearly put effort into preparation for a field outside his expertise.

However, although he emphasized avoiding AI hallucinations from the start, the result was still full of misinterpretations and unintelligible content.

How do you ask an AI to do a “patent strategy”?

The term “patent strategy” encompasses too many dimensions: the breakdown of different features, application timing, strategies for patent families, various countries, etc. This is even before touching upon the detailed specification and the claim architecture within each patent.

This entire scope is what we mean by patent strategy. The critical issue is that current AI cannot dissect these multi-layered, nuanced issues. Consequently, AI is prone to generating content that appears plausible on the surface but is nonsensical.

The second problem is that because the instructor lacked the “common sense” of the patent field, he completely failed to detect the obvious problems in the generated results. This led to the absurd outcome of hallucination stacking upon hallucination through multiple rounds of dialogue.

Honestly, this result was probably destined from the course planning stage. Why?

The instructor actually stated at the beginning of the course: “I am not a patent attorney, so I can only understand your daily work essentially through a language model.”

But he underestimated that AI does not understand either; and someone who does not understand patents cannot help the AI understand.

Patents are not an easy profession to grasp.

In fact, I know many patent professionals who are masters of AI techniques. By using only general-purpose ChatGPT, they have increased the speed and quality of their case handling many times over. This is something that people from other professions cannot imitate.