China’s “Abnormal” Patent Actually Made it to the Supreme Court

Imagine spending years in litigation and burning through legal fees to claim ownership of a patent, only to discover that the invention itself was completely fabricated.

Company A and Company B were locked in a battle after a technical team migrated from A to B. The defecting employees filed for a patent involving complex biochemical processes shortly after joining their new employer.

Company A sued, claiming the patent belonged to them. The first-instance court ruled for shared ownership. Neither side was happy, so both appealed.

Just as the appellate battle heated up, the CNIPA issued a notice flagging the patent as “Abnormal”.

For those unfamiliar with “Abnormal Patent Applications” in China: This is a classification the CNIPA uses to filter out filings that have nothing to do with protecting innovation. Instead, these applications are designed to game the system by seeking illegitimate benefits or fabricating performance metrics. Common forms include mass filings, plagiarized text, or “patchworked” content. Basically, it serves as a catch-all tool for the authorities to strike down any applications they simply don’t want to see. It must be said that this standard has always been somewhat elusive.

This designation triggered a shift in the Supreme Court’s strategy. They asked the inventors a simple question: “Did you actually do the experiments?”

The inventors confessed: The process was drafted based on public literature. The “experimental data” was hypothetical. It was deduced to assume success. No actual lab work was performed to verify the parameters.

The Supreme Court ruled: Patent applications or patent rights that are not based on genuine inventive activities and are obtained in violation of the principle of good faith shall not be protected by law.

What is interesting here isn’t just that the data was faked, but that this “ghost patent” survived examination and a full first-instance trial. It made it all the way to the Supreme Court before the truth came out.

The most fascinating nuance of the ruling is that the Supreme Court didn’t actually rely on the Patent Law to dismiss the case. Why? Because there is no “Good Faith” provision in the Patent Law. Instead, the judges reached back to the foundational Article 7 of the General Provisions of the Civil Law.

I suspect this unique chain of events is unlikely to occur anywhere else.

Reference: https://lnkd.in/g7fiKZtP