Ex officio investigation in Taiwan Patent Litigation

Image from the original Medium article.
Image from the original Medium article.

Last year, I attended a seminar with lawyers and judges from Taiwan, as well as patent attorneys from various countries. One of the topics was a critical aspect of patent litigation in Taiwan: the delicate balance between the judge’s role in seeking truth and the adversarial principle. A Senior Patent Litigator from a major Taiwan law firm kicked off the discussion by presenting a common scenario, sparking a lively debate featuring insights from academia, the judiciary, and international practitioners.

When Does ex officio investigation Cross the Line?

The Presenting Attorney illustrated the core issue with a scenario from practice:

  1. A defendant in a patent infringement lawsuit challenges the patent’s validity using prior art containing 300 compounds, specifically selecting Compounds A and B for their argument.
  2. During the proceedings, the judge voluntarily asks both parties whether Compound C, also present in the prior art but not initially raised by the defendant, would render the patent obvious (lacking inventiveness).
  3. Following oral arguments on this point, the court ultimately rules the patent invalid based on Compound C.

The problem, the Presenting Attorney noted, is that the judge’s question often prompts experienced defense counsel to immediately adopt Compound C into their arguments. This effectively transforms the judge’s inquiry into a party’s assertion, obscuring the procedural origins in the final written judgment and raising due process concerns.

To explore how Taiwan’s courts navigate the boundaries of ex officio investigation (where the court actively investigates facts), the Presenting Attorney analysed several administrative court decisions concerning patent invalidation actions, and concluded that while Patent Act §75 provides some boundary for ex officio actions in administrative appeals, Taiwan’s Code of Civil Procedure lacks clear statutory limits for judicial intervention in civil infringement cases, which are primarily governed by the adversarial principle.

His fundamental question remained: Is the goal of civil litigation absolute truth-finding, or ensuring fairness between the disputing parties? He observed a paradox: Taiwan strictly adheres to party presentation in criminal and administrative proceedings, but less consistently so in civil matters.

Perspectives from Panelists and Practitioners

  • A professor from National Taiwan University suggested the judge raising Compound C might be justifiable if it’s a matter already considered known to the court. This could be relevant if the information is already present in the case file, meaning it wouldn’t need to be formally submitted as evidence.
  • A Presiding Judge from the Taiwan IP Court acknowledged Taiwan’s civil procedure isn’t purely adversarial, citing articles allowing judicial clarification and evidence gathering. However, judges exercise more restraint when both parties have qualified legal counsel.
  • The German Perspective: A Judge from the District Court Munich / UPC Local Division Munich said the roles are clear in Germany: parties provide facts and evidence; the judge applies the law.
  • The US Perspective: A US Patent attorney said the judge’s role is primarily an arbiter. However, he conceded that judges might offer “hints” or ask probing questions during claim construction or proceedings. For example, during claim construction, they might ask something like, “Have you considered looking at it this way?” or comment during the litigation process, “This seems a bit unclear.” Experienced lawyers will often pick up on these cues and adjust their strategy accordingly.
  • The Japan Perspective: A Japan patent attorney described Japan as strictly adhering to the adversarial principle. A judge introducing Compound C as a basis for invalidity would be unacceptable unless a party explicitly adopted that argument. While suggestions from the judge might occur (similar to the US), the judgment cannot rely on arguments or evidence interpretations not presented by the parties. He noted a slight flexibility: if the legal argument is the same, but the judge points to different evidence within the record supporting it (e.g., finding support in paragraph 20 instead of the party’s cited paragraphs 10–11), that might be permissible.

Conclusion: An Ongoing Quest for Balance

The seminar underscored the persistent tension surrounding the judge’s role in Taiwanese patent litigation. While administrative procedure offers some statutory guidance on ex officio powers, civil procedure remains a complex interplay between the adversarial principle and judicial discretion.